Hospital Accountability Should Be a Bipartisan Priority

With the midterms behind us, it is time to look for public policy issues where Republicans and Democrats can come together and make life easier for everyday Americans. Healthcare affordability should be at the top of that list.

For years, Washington has focused its healthcare affordability efforts on insurance companies and pharmaceutical manufacturers, but any serious effort to lower costs must also confront the waste, fraud, and abuse occurring within the nation’s nonprofit hospitals systems.

Hospital services prices rose more than 280% between 2000 and 2025, according to data highlighted by HospitalFacts.org, roughly three times the increase in overall consumer prices due to inflation. Those charges help drive health insurance premiums upward. As hospitals demand higher payment for care, employers and families ultimately shoulder the cost through premiums, deductibles, and pressure on wages.

Rice University researchers found that average CEO compensation at independent nonprofit hospitals reached approximately $1.3 million in 2019. Even more revealing, their analysis linked executive pay to hospital profits, while finding no association between providing more charity care and higher pay.

For example, take AdventHealth in Florida. According to its tax filings, the nonprofit hospital system made $1.46 billion in profits in 2024 and paid its CEO a staggering $8.5 million. The hospital system controls roughly 72% of the Daytona Beach and 47% of the Orlando markets and boasts $14 billion in total assets. In 2024, AdventHealth’s charity care accounted for 3.8% of total expenses.

For AdventHealth and many hospital systems like it, there is an extraordinary incentive structure for institutions receiving tax advantages on the strength of their public mission. If the board rewards financial performance without placing comparable value on helping patients who cannot pay, the public deserves to ask whose interests the institution is really serving.

Some hospitals absolutely need their tax exemptions. A struggling rural hospital keeping an emergency department open may be the only thing standing between a community and a dangerously long drive for care. Protecting those hospitals is essential.

Wealthy urban systems, however, should stop using those facilities as political cover. A sprawling hospital corporation with investment holdings, real estate interests, sports stadium naming rights, and highly paid executives must demonstrate exactly what taxpayers receive in return for its exemptions. In New York, “nonprofit” Northwell Health, the state’s largest healthcare provider, has even launched its own movie studio. Positive margins and growing assets make that question more urgent. Nonprofit status permits a surplus. It should also carry a meaningful obligation to serve the public.

Consider the experience at the family kitchen table. Imagine a single mother staring at a $500 medical bill she cannot afford while a collections notice forces her to choose between paying that debt and purchasing groceries. Before anyone pursues her, a charitable hospital should make every reasonable effort to identify and deliver the financial assistance she qualifies for.

The Lown Institute’s 2025 review of 2,500 hospitals found that 59% allowed at least one extraordinary collection action in their policies, while eligibility for free care varied widely. A promise of charity means little if patients cannot understand it, access it, or receive it before their account moves into collections.

Thankfully, Washington is finally asking harder questions. On April 28, the House Ways and Means Committee brought the CEOs of HCA Healthcare, CommonSpirit Health, New York-Presbyterian, and ECU Health before Congress. Lawmakers examined hospital pricing, tax exemptions, and the financial incentives that reward consolidation and higher charges.

The Trump administration has also stepped up its enforcement. In June, the Associated Press reported that 519 hospitals had received federal warnings or corrective-action-plan requests over price-transparency deficiencies. While some hospitals attributed their notices to technical errors, which they subsequently corrected, the governing principle remains straightforward. Hospitals must meet disclosure rules, and patients deserve accurate, usable prices.

Congress must keep pushing. During the lame-duck session, when we will likely see another reconciliation effort, holding nonprofit hospitals accountable could fit right in. Congress should require meaningful charity care standards in return for tax advantages, scrutinize executive compensation, investments, and real estate transactions, make financial assistance easier to obtain, enforce price transparency, and investigate waste, fraud, and abuse wherever the evidence leads. Ultimately, a hospital’s tax-exempt status should be earned through measurable public benefit and subject to consequences when hospitals fail to live up to their obligations.

With midterm elections in the rearview mirror, members on both sides of the aisle must realize that hospital accountability is a winning bipartisan issue. Families across the political spectrum want affordable care, honest prices, and fair treatment when they need care. Lawmakers willing to challenge powerful hospital systems can show voters they understand those everyday concerns. As Americans wake up to the gap between nonprofit hospitals’ charitable image and their real corporate behavior, Congress should turn that scrutiny into lasting reform.

Christopher Sheeron is founder and president of Action for Health, a national nonprofit organization working to ensure fair outcomes for critical healthcare issues.

 



Comment
Show comments Hide Comments


Related Articles